The World Bank - Working for a world free of poverty

Views menu

blog.worldbank.org

September 2008

Les dépenses publiques perdues au Tchad

Le Tchad est l'un des pays les plus pauvres en Afrique subsaharienne classé 100ème sur 103 pays selon l'indice de pauvreté. Ses indicateurs de santé sont souvent en deçà de ceux des pays avec un niveau de développement comparable. Malgré une augmentation significative des ressources publiques allouées à la santé au cours de la dernière décennie, l'incidence du paludisme, la diarrhée, les infections respiratoires, la méningite et le choléra reste élevée et les indicateurs sociaux restent stagnants. Pourquoi les ressources publiques ne permettent-elles pas de produire de meilleurs indicateurs?

When you do win, then the hard work starts

I’ve been reflecting on further lessons learned from our project that I could share with everyone. I’ve come up a number and they’re all interlinked. The first is that inevitably when you’re implementing innovative projects in complex contexts, you’re going to need to work with partners.

Why the development agenda must embrace migration

1. Migration is an exception rather than the rule. Only 200 million or 3% of world population are international migrants; 97% are not. Most people like to be rooted where they are born, unless they are uprooted by economic factors.

2. Over 90% of international migrants are economic migrants who have left home to work for someone abroad. The implication is that migration generates economic gains for the migrants, their employers in destination countries, and their families back home. Yet, considering that most people stay at home, migration is not a substitute for development and job creation at home.

3. Contrary to popular perception, migrants from developing countries do not always move to rich countries. About half of them reside in other poor developing countries. In other words, migration is not always "south-north".  Many developing countries have to deal with the complexities associated with not only emigration of their people, but immigration of people from other countries.

If It Tastes Bad, Spit It Out: Social Norms in the Fight against Corruption

In both the developed and developing world, I've come across people in varying positions of power either hinting or stating in no uncertain terms that I would not receive a government service without "greasing the wheel."  Despite wide disparities between low- and high- income country contexts, these experiences left the same bad taste in my mouth.  But corrupt practices, including bribery, aren't equal and, in a larger sense, understanding the differences among them puts us in better stead in the global fight against corruption.  In a previous post, CommGAP requested feedback on an anti-corruption learning event jointly organized with the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime.  One of the themes of the event will be the role of communication in shifting social norms toward condemning corrupt everyday practices.
 

 

Faut-il dévaluer?

Etant donné l’appréciation de l’Euro vis-à-vis du dollar, la question de la parité du Franc CFA (qui est fixé à l’Euro) doit être encore soulevée.  L’appréciation est comparable à celle des années 1985-1993 [voir graphique].  Pendant cette période, les économies des pays de la zone CFA ont connu une forte diminution de leur compétitivité, des exportations, et de croissance économique.  Dans la plupart des pays, la pauvreté a augmenté.   Il faut se rappeler que le

Real-financial sector links

When asked about the East Asian financial crisis of the late 1990s, Ethiopian Prime Minister Meles Zenawi reportedly said, “I wish we had their problems.”  I was reminded of this quip when thinking about the current financial crisis in the U.S. and its possible impact on Africa.  In the U.S., there is a constant fear that turmoil in financial markets will spill over to the real sector—in terms of slow growth and unemployment. 

A recent paper by Hamid Davoodi shows that, in Swaziland, the problem is a lack of real-financial sector linkages.  Most financial sector indicators—private sector lending, money supply and bank deposits as a percentage of GDP—are going down, not up.  One reason may be that about 60 percent of land is owned by tribal chiefs and held in public trust.  Since no one has ownership rights, no one can use land as collateral, and so borrowing and lending are limited.

Financial Market Turmoil and Africa

My colleagues and I are trying to think through the implications for Africa of the recent turmoil in global financial markets. Here are four propositions.

1. African banking systems are unlikely to experience the turbulence of the U.S. banking system.  African banks retain loans they originate on their balance sheets, the interbank market is small, and the market for securitized or derivative instruments is either small or nonexistent.  Even though some African countries’ banking systems have significant foreign ownership, the parent banks are typically not in the U.S.  Furthermore, the foreign ownership share in the largest economies, Nigeria and South Africa, is less than five percent (compared with a developing-country average of 40 percent).

Fridays Academy: Gender and the Labor Market

This Friday we finish this section on "Gender and the Labor Market" with a brief summary of what we have seen in previous weeks.  Next Friday we will start "Gender Budgeting". As usual, from Raj Nallari and Breda Griffith's lecture notes.

 

Conclusion

During the last few weeks we have examined gender inequalities in the labor market. First a number of reasons were considered for why gender inequality exists especially in the labor market.  Issues regarding specialization and segmentation, women’s reproductive role and wage gaps were noted.  We went on to exam the progress being made in the world of work by women by focusing on the indicators of labor market performance – the labor force participation ratio, the unemployment rate, wage rates, and skills. We concluded by examining two measures of labor market performance – employment by sector and the status of employment. Data disaggregated by gender on the latter indicator has only recently been made publicly available.  

Zoellick Visits DM2008

Among the visitors to 2008 Global Development Marketplace: Sustainable Agriculture for Development today was World Bank Group President Robert B. Zoellick.

...And the Winners Are...

Twenty-two project winners collected their crystal awards and grant checks in the 2008 Global Development Marketplace: Sustainable Agriculture for Development competition this morning.

Two Who Won...

Among the 22 winning projects in the DM2008 competition was Agricultural Cooperatives for Biodiversity Conservation in Cambodia, and collecting the award were Enterprise Planner Adviser Karen Nielsen and Technical Adviser Tom Clements (in photo).

"W'e're quite excited about having our project recognized as one of the more innovative ones," said Nielsen, clutching her team's award.

Under the project, "Wildlife-friendly" products grown in conservation-protected areas in Cambodia will be marketed nationally, including at tourism centers, by cooperatives in 10 villages.

...And One Who Didn't

Subhas Managuli made it to the finalists' circle, buthis Best Practices Foundation proposal to improve livestock health for 2,000 small farmers in 20 villages in India didn't make the final cut that produced the 22 winners who were announced Friday morning.

"The idea is good, and I'll try to pitch it to other agencies," Managuli said as the closing ceremony wound up in the Atrium.  "I'm not going to give up. Absolutely."

DM2008 as a Learning Experience

While their booths were temporarily closed during the exhibition, finalists, along with development community representatives, participated in Knowledge Exchange technical assistance workshops -- like this one on capacity building.

A new remittance price database brings much-needed transparency

I was in Vienna last week to attend an impressive event called the Public-Private Partnership on Remittances, organized by my colleagues Massimo Cirasino and Peer Stein. Amid the technocratic, technical, and tactical treatise on payment systems, a high point for me was the launch of Remittance Prices Worldwide, a new World Bank remittance price database.

For the first time there is one database, painstakingly gathered and meticulously organized with the lay user in mind, dedicated to the cost of sending remittances in over 120 important remittance corridors. Transparency is expected to help educate consumers and generate competition among remittance service providers. Indeed a few stats are eye openers: it costs less than $8 to send $200 from Spain to Brazil (less than 4%). By contrast, sending the same amount from Germany to China can cost nearly $50 (or 25%)!

Leaders have been talking about reducing remittance costs since 2004, if not earlier. Yet, until now, there were no real indicators of how costs are falling. Mexico began putting out remittance cost data from about 13 US cities to several Mexican cities, and we saw a 56% decline in remittance costs between 1999 and 2004. The hope is that the new database will have a similar cost reduction effect. That would reduce the drain on poor migrants' incomes and increase their ability to send more help home.

 

International Transactions in Remittances: Guide for Balance of Payments Statistics Compilers and Users

As part of the effort to improve estimates of remittance flows within the framework of Balance of Payments statistics, the IMF's Statistics Department, together with the "Luxembourg Group," has completed a draft of the new International Transactions in Remittances: Guide for Compilers and Users (RCG). The chapters and appendices are presented at the IMF's website.

Comments on the draft RCG, with particular reference to content, clarity, and detail, are welcome and should be sent using the form provided on the IMF website by October 24, 2008. Notes for reviewers are also provided on the website. A revised version of the RCG is expected to be posted on the website by the end of the year.

3 Past Winners and the Lessons They Learned

Three DM2008 jurors who are past grant winners are sharing their well-learned lessons with the hundred finalists.

Take 2006 winner Florence Cassassuce (in photo at right), who brought her water-purifying UV-light bucket to 900 villagers on the rural outskirts of La Paz in Baja California, Mexcio. Cassassuce, implementing her project with the advice of World Bank Senior Environmental Specialist Ricardo Hernandez Murillo, installed 3,500 buckets toward the goal of 6,00, ahead of schedule. But the original buckets didn't always work well, especially in the field, and improvements had to be made with better, and faster, plastic-injection manufacturing.

The dilemmas of measuring corruption: is there an agreement of where should we move on?

As corruption issues around the world seem to be endless, so is the debate about the best way to develop and use corruption indicators.  Whether aggregate or disaggregated; whether actionable or not; whether perception-based or experience-based; whether they should measure inputs or outputs; and whether assessments should be locally-owned or conducted by international institutions are just part of the on-going discussions in open forums and informal chats.

This month we witnessed the publication of two valuable efforts that move towards different directions on corruption measurement: (i) the 2008 Corruption Perception Index launched this week by Transparency International; and (ii) “A Users’ Guide to Measuring Corruption,” published at the beginning of this month by the UNDP Oslo Governance Centre and Global Integrity

While Transparency International’s approach relies on composite, cross-country and perception-based indicators, the User’s Guide suggests –among other things– the need for more locally owned assessments that capture the voice and experience of the poor and minority groups, as well as actionable measurements that give a better sense of what needs to be reformed.

ARD's Juergen Voegele on How the Bank Will Work With the Winners

As the recently named Director of the Agriculture and Rural Development Department -- one of DM2008's funders --Juergen Voegele is leading a vigorous effort to re-energize and broaden the World Bank's commitment to agricultural development. During his peripatetic rounds of the competition, Voegele sat down for this mini-interview:

Q. What are your impressions of what you see on the floor of the exhibition?

A Juror Describes the Final Winnowing Process

Among the 36 jurors for the DM2008 grant competition was Thomas Pomeroy, a former USDA bilateral trade director in key regions of the world who now consults in Sub-Saharan Africa. We did this mini-interview with Pomeroy:

 Q. As part of Team 10, you looked at 12 agribusiness proposals. What was your major criterion in scoring them?

Sustainable Charcoal Production by Women in Mozambique Is Peer Choice Award Winner

A $199,050 project that would produce sustainable charcoal from bamboo and benefit 250 women entrepreneurs in Mozambique is the winner of the Peer Choice Award by the 100 DM2008 finalists.

The Politics of Non-Transparent Aid Flows

My attention has been tickled by the news that at the recent High Level Forum on Aid Effectiveness in Accra, Ghana, donors apparently agreed to launch an initiative known as the International Aid Transparency Initiative. Under the initiative, according to the DFID press release on the subject, donors have agreed to give:

- Full and detailed information on all aid in each country affected
- Details and costs of individual projects and their aims
- Reliable information on future aid to improve planning by recipient governments.

I hope the initiative will be seriously implemented. But it will not be easy. And the main reason it will not be easy is that the instinct of the technocracy that dominates every aspect of international development is to be non-transparent.

IFC Ag Chief Oscar Chemerinski on DM2008

Oscar Chemerinski, Director of the Agribusiness Department at the International Finance Corp. -- the commercial development arm of the World Bank Group -- gave this mini-interview at DM2008:

Q. What's your reaction to what you see on the floor among the booths of the hundred finalists?

Past Grant Winner Flo Cassassuce Shares Her Experience

Florence Cassassuce, who won a DM2006 grant ($170,310) for her UV buckets to disinfect water in rural Mexico, shared her on-the-ground experiences during this morning's opening ceremonies.