The World Bank - Working for a world free of poverty

Views menu

blog.worldbank.org

November 2008

How can China use its foreign reserves to help?

A reader of the blog sent me the following interesting comment and question:

You wrote in your blog entry ("China’s growth surprises on the downside"): 'Because China saved during the boom times -- through a fiscal surplus and through reserve accumulation -- it has considerable scope to stimulate its economy if the global slowdown threatens a hard landing in China.’ I'm always intrigued by these references to China's reserves. As I follow the financial press and websites like yours, I never see any explanation of how China would use its forex reserves to help itself (or the help the world recover from the economic crisis). I have seen, however, that China has already invested the bulk of those reserves in U.S. government bonds, leaving it with little scope for any other kinds of action involving these sums. [Recently], news reported that China has surpassed Japan as the largest holder of such bonds. Can you comment?

China’s saving through a fiscal surplus puts it in a good position to directly stimulate its economy through public spending. It has low debt and could stimulate the economy a lot without raising fears of indebtedness and inflation. As implied by your comment, foreign reserves are trickier to use. China cannot spend these directly on its domestic economy without first converting them to Yuan, which would have the kind of large effect on the exchange rate that the country wants to avoid.

Fridays Academy: Gender and Monetary Policy

As usual on Fridays, from Raj Nallari and Breda Griffith's lecture notes.

Braunstein and Heintz (2006) report that the costs of inflation in terms of reduced employment are disproportionately borne by women.  They compiled data for 51 “inflation reduction episodes” in 17 low- and middle-income countries for the period 1970-2003.  To assess the employment effects of inflation reduction periods, they looked at actual employment trends during each inflation reduction episode, disaggregated by gender, and compared these to long-run employment trends (estimated by applying a Hodrik-Prescott filter to the employment series).  They also examine indicators that suggest how monetary policy responded during inflation reduction episodes using a similar approach. We compare average short-term real interest rates, growth rates of the real money supply, and indicators of the real exchange rate to their long-run trends to see if these variables deviated from trend during inflation reduction episodes. Their preliminary observations are worth repeating and presented below:

Money transfers conference in London on November 17-18: New innovations in money transfers amidst crisis

I recently made a presentation on our outlook for remittances at the Money Transfers London conference. The discussions were lively and interesting and the topics included the impact of the EU payment services directive (PSD) and other regulatory changes for the money transfer industry, innovations in smart cards and mobile money transfers, and the impact of the current economic crisis, among others (see full conference agenda).

One development I found interesting was efforts to standardize training for Money Laundering Reporting Officers (MLROs) in the money transfer firms. To remain relevant in times of changing rules and regulations, these officials will need to be tuned to the messages coming from regulators not only through directives and websites, but also from speeches and interviews in the media.  

This conference and others organized by industry bodies such as the IAMTN are very useful because they provide a space for private sector participants to interact with regulators and development agencies, clarify new regulations and laws, and let us hear from practitioners on new developments and emerging technologies.

DM2005 winner to scale up its activities after winning Dubai Award

In my last posting, I mentioned the importance of securing new funding to scale up activities. I’ve got some great news to share today and that is that our efforts to secure more financial resources have borne fruit in that we’ve just received news that we’re one of 12 winners of the biennial Dubai Awards.

I Hate Thee but, Alas, I Need Thee

Each time I attend a meeting where public officials are gathered and the subject of the mass media comes up, the room lights up. The stories of deep frustration with the media simply flow out of them like melted butter out of a jug. The complaints are legion:

  • Those terrible journalists distort my views.
  • The media are instruments of terror...virtually.
  • They don't get anything serious; they are lazy and uninformed.
  • They are in bed with sinister forces, and corrupt proprietors.
  • They are not to be trusted at all.
  • As the discussion progresses, the authoritarian impulse comes out. You hear calls for strict regulation of the mass media in the particular developing country. Yes, the officials say, the media must be brought to heel, reigned in.

China experts to answer questions in live online chat

Amid all the news of the slowing global economy, I’m not sure anyone was too surprised that the World Bank’s latest China economic projections estimate the country’s economic growth, despite remaining relatively strong, will continue to slow in 2009. The latest edition of the China Quarterly Update, released Monday, also says that to continue growth, China needs to utilize already announced stimulus policies to rebalance its economy and improve standard of living and support long-term development.

Have questions about the report? Do you wonder what the future holds for China? Our own bloggers David Dollar and Louis Kuijs, who authored the report, will answer questions Monday in a live online chat. You can join them on Dec. 1 at 8 a.m. EST (13:00 GMT/UTC and 9pm in Beijing), or submit your questions now. Check it out here.

Reshaping Economic Geography

The World Development Report, the World Bank's flagship publication, looks this year at Economic Geography (a very current issue thank you also to the Nobel Prize).

The full report and more related information available on-line.

Some comments on the report from blogs: ODI Blog, From Poverty to Power

Related, see also our previous comment, Krugman on Economic Geography.

Cautious optimism about condition of Chinese exports

We cannot be too optimistic on China’s exports, even though we think the country’s competitiveness is still strong. Image credit: scobleizer at Flickr under a Creative Commons license.

As we were looking at recent developments as background for our China Quarterly Update, which was released yesterday, we had to make up our minds about how well China’s exports are doing. This was necessary because there are conflicting answers to this question. On the one hand, we are reading many reports from the coastal provinces, Guangdong in particular, about how bad things are there in the export industries, with factories closing and migrant workers going back to rural areas. On the other hand, the data on overall export developments suggests exports have held up reasonably well so far, with overall exports in real terms still far outgrowing overall world import growth, implying continued gains in global market share for China (see left hand figure below).

An important part of the answer lies in the fact that the export performance differs markedly between sectors. Exports of light manufacturing products, such as textiles and toys, are by now lower than a year ago in real terms (see right hand figure below), while real exports of (higher value added) machinery and equipment are still growing by over 30 percent year-on-year. Exports of light manufactures have been hit by cost increases as well as weak overall foreign demand—which matters a lot because China now produces the bulk of global production in certain sectors, such as toys. On the other hand, China’s exports of machinery and equipment still occupy modest market shares globally, and China’s strong underlying competitiveness means that its exporters can continue to gain market share even in more challenging global circumstances.

Jobs, Jobs, Jobs

The December issue of Poverty in Focus, the magazine published by UNDP's International Poverty Centre, is out. This issue is fully devoted to the linkages between employment, economic growth and poverty reduction.

"What is the role of employment in the nexus of economic growth, poverty reduction and progress towards achievement of the UN Millennium Development Goals? Although employment is not an explicit component of the MDGs, it has a key role in economic and social development.

As labour is the main resource that most poor people are endowed with, labour intensive growth is the most effective way to reduce poverty. Employment is the key source of income, consumption and other material aspects of improved livelihoods. Moreover, it enhances also other dimensions of wellbeing including skills, physical abilities and self-respect."

Access the full issue on-line: Jobs, Jobs, Jobs - The Policy Challenge

Reducing risk from natural disasters takes partnerships, teamwork

Image credit: simonpocock at Flickr under a Creative Commons license.

If you want to know what movies are being shown on flights across the Pacific, ask me or my World Bank colleagues in the East Asia and Pacific region's Disaster Risk Management team. We have been passing one another by plane for the past month and a half. Responsible for coordinating disaster risk management efforts and activities for the region, we are a busy group, no doubt about it.

I have been in China for the past few weeks supporting the country team to appraise a package of support to China for recovery efforts following the May 12, 2008 Wenchuan Earthquake. One colleague participated in the recent Global Facility for Disaster Reduction and Recovery Consultative Group meetings in Copenhagen, Denmark and is now in Jakarta, Indonesia working with field staff, the country’s government, and partners on mainstreaming risk reduction into development programs. Another colleague of mine just returned from the Philippines and Vietnam, where she was stranded by flooding in Hanoi. In fact, she had to wade through knee-deep water when leaving a meeting at the Ministry of Finance. Of course, this represents just part of the team, since we work with a broader network of staff based in country offices who manage country-level programs and projects.

From Poverty to Power

 “When I was a boy of fourteen,” Mark Twain once said, “my father was so ignorant I could hardly stand to have the old man around. But when I got to be twenty-one, I was astonished by how much he'd learned in seven years.”

My relationship with the book From Poverty to Power by Duncan Green of Oxfam is a bit like that between Mark Twain and his father. Despite all the critical things said about neoclassical economics, the World Bank and the Washington consensus in the book, I find myself agreeing fully with the conclusions of the book. 

Regional Movements for Media Reform

Much has been said lately about the prospects for global institutions to promote media democracy and good governance. The jury is still out, however. How can a diversity of trasnational actors, including intergovernment bodies, donors, UN agencies, civic groups and business, be effective? Are all actors equally positioned? If national governments retain power over key decisions shaping media environments, how do global actors manage to influence opportunities for media pluralism and participation?

Latin America offers an interesting petri dish to examine the germination of regional movements promoting media pluralism.

How relevant was the G20 Summit for emerging Asia?

Image credit: downingstreet at Flickr under a Creative Commons license.

Now that the dust has settled and the traffic is back to normal here in Washington, DC after the G20 Summit this past weekend, what’s next? Will the G20 Statement, with its 47 actions, have any relevance in emerging Asia? Well, the answer is yes and no (you didn’t actually expect a clear answer, did you?).

On the “yes” side of the ledger, the first immediate impact of the G20 Summit was an explicit recognition that the major emerging markets matter in the global financial system, which the Financial Times recently claimed “marked a shift in economic power.” China, Indonesia, and Korea (and of course, Japan) were participants in the meeting, and although these countries were not viewed as leading the agenda, they certainly had an influence on the final outcome.

Fridays Academy: Gender and Monetary Policy

 As usual on Fridays, from Raj Nallari and Breda Griffith's lecture notes.

 

Gender and Monetary Policy: Introduction

The monetary system in any country comprises of banks and other financial institutions, such as credit unions, micro-credit schemes, and housing societies.  In more developed countries, stock markets, investment banks, insurance companies and other institutions also take deposits and provide financial services.  Monetary policy instruments are mainly money supply and interest rates, while regulations related to facilitating transactions of payments, assets, debts and credit.
 
The broad objective of monetary policy conducted by Central Bank of a country is to maintain low inflation (that will also ensure low real interest rates) and stable and realistic exchange rates by managing money supply and setting interest rates.  Low inflation, low real interest rates, and realistic exchange rates benefit the poor, while high inflation hampers growth, and the poor are unable to protect their consumption levels.  However, moderate inflation in the range of about 20-30% is observed not to have an adverse effect on GDP growth. But, inflation erodes the real incomes and as such, is harmful to the poor, who already have lower incomes. Overvalued exchange rates harm the living standards of the rural poor who are predominantly women who depend upon agricultural exports.

Chat live with World Bank VP for poverty reduction and economic management

The global economic and financial crisis continues to unfold. In such an uncertain time, there are a lot of questions and few certainties. Leaders around the world have recognized that the developing world will surely take its fair share of punches. The World Bank, committed to fighting poverty, has announced it will increase lending to help support the developing countries, but what else can it do to help?

On Monday, Danny Leipziger, who heads up a network of 700 economists and professionals working on policy, lending, and analysis for the World Bank’s client countries, will answer your questions in a live online discussion Nov. 24 at 12 p.m. EST. Head over to this page now to submit questions, or check back Monday morning to read his answers.

UPDATED: The time of the live chat has been changed. It will now take place on Nov. 24 at 12:00 p.m. EST.

International Finance and Growth in Developing Countries

 

The Commission on Growth and Development has published the paper International Finance and Growth in Developing Countries: What Have We Learned?, by Maurice Obstfeld.

"Despite an abundance of cross?section, panel, and event studies, there is strikingly little convincing documentation of direct positive impacts of financial opening on the economic welfare levels or growth rates of developing countries. The econometric difficulties are similar to those that bedevil the literature on trade openness and growth, though if anything, they are more severe in the context of international finance. There is also little systematic evidence that financial opening raises welfare indirectly by promoting collateral reforms of economic institutions or policies. At the same time, opening the financial account does appear to raise the frequency and severity of economic crises. Nonetheless, developing countries continue to move in the direction of further financial openness. A plausible explanation is that financial development is a concomitant of successful economic growth, and a growing financial sector in an economy open to trade cannot long be insulated from cross?border financial flows. This survey discusses the policy framework in which financial globalization is most likely to prove beneficial for developing countries. The reforms developing countries need to carry out to make their economies safe for international asset trade are the same reforms they need to carry out to curtail the power of entrenched economic interests and liberate the economy’s productive potential."

How about next G-20 Summit on good governance for sound financial markets?

The first G-20 summit, focused on the financial crisis, just took place this past weekend.  When measured against expectations of such gatherings, there were some accomplishments.  Such as in trade:  the collective pledge to avoid raising any trade and investment barriers, or the promise to ‘strive’ for a deal on the stalled Doha round.  And the  summit's ‘action plan’ holds promise. 

The declaration includes a generic list of a plethora of financial sector  ‘principles’ and many areas of work.  But at least it is comprehensive in scope, touching on most of the right ‘buttons’.  It provides space to work concretely on real issues.

Sustaining growth: China’s need for a new growth model

China’s big stimulus plan will help keep the economy growing at a healthy rate, though 2009 will be a rough year with probably the slowest growth in nearly 20 years. While China applies stimulus to deal with the immediate downturn, it would be good to be thinking ahead. China needs a new growth model, and it should evaluate its possible spending plans both in terms of immediate stimulus and in terms of contribution to this new growth model.

China needs a new growth model because after the global downturn comes to an end, exports will never again play the same role as they have in the past two decades. I would argue that the four basic principles that account for the Chinese miracle since 1978 remain valid, each of which needs some tweaking in the new environment.

Communication and Anti-Corruption: Day 3 (of 3)

Vienna International Center, Austria -- The third and final day of the CommGAP-United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) communication and anti-corruption learning event featured the following topics: the role of communication in changing social norms and behavior that support corruption; the communicative dimensions of anti-corruption bodies; and a brainstorming session on the ways in which UNODC and CommGAP can support the global anti-corruption community of practice.

Communication and Anti-Corruption: Day 2

Vienna International Center, Austria -- Today’s sessions revolved around the following topics: the roles of media and civil society campaigns in the removal and resignation of corrupt leaders; framing anti-corruption messages for multiple stakeholders; and getting citizens to differentiate between real corruption and rumors of corruption.

 

Your “Good Leader” Might be Another Person’s “Worst Nightmare”

This summer I was asked to evaluate Timor-Leste’s Leadership and Communication Capacity for National Renewal Program (LCCNR) and provide strategic recommendations for the future of the program. I did so with great interest and developed a high appreciation for the LCCNR. Its design is built on extensive research and reveals deep insight into Timor’s culture and current governance challenges. I believe it is a program of potentially great value for the future and stability of Timor-Leste.

A communiqué that actually says something

Most communiqués of international summits are rather bland documents that represent phrasing that everyone could agree on. The communiqué from this weekend’s G-20 summit is a little more forthright than usual, but as Dani Rodrik notes, doesn’t go far enough in holding the G-20 accountable for its actions. By contrast, the communiqué from the November 13-14 Tunis meeting of African finance ministers and central bank governors contains several statements that demonstrate a sense of mutual accountability. First, the ministers and governorsagreed…to deepen economic reforms in the full conviction that such reforms have served African countries well, yielded strong macroeconomic stability, fostered growth and resilience to external shocks.” 

Emerging e-government themes in the Obama administration

"Let us be the generation that reshapes our economy to compete in the digital age. Let's set high standards for our schools and give them the resources they need to succeed. Let's recruit a new army of teachers, and give them better pay and more support in exchange for more accountability.