Syndicate content

Add new comment

Thanks, Muraleedharan. You’re right, of course, that studies like this cost money, and it’s good to ask what we learn from the money that’s been spent. As I argued in my reply to Prashanth, this study really did generate important new knowledge. Was it worth the cost? I guess that depends in part on what impact it is, and on that we’ll have to be patient. On the ethics issue, I think I’d be very concerned if providers were operating at full capacity and taking a long time over a consultation. In that case, fake patients would actually depriving a real patient of care, or making them wait a long time for it. But it looks like these providers aren’t seeing that many patients a day, and any extra wait for the real patient is just the length of the fake patient’s consultation, which as you say is just a minute or two.