It’s been an unusually severe rainy season in some parts of Lao PDR, with several typhoons passing over after making landfall in
A large hydropower project like Nam Theun 2 (NT2) has a significant effect on water flows around the project, and so inevitably people begin to question whether NT2 is somehow making the local floods worse. Questions around project’s role in exacerbating natural floods started even before Nam Theun 2 started operating (see a blog post on this back in 2009), and it has sporadically been blamed during this wet season as well. A lot of these arguments stem from some pretty basic misunderstandings of how NT2 works, so although this information is already in the public domain, I thought I’d produce a simple summary here with reference to the attached map.
NT2 has a 4,000km2 watershed area (area 1 on map), made up of the Nakai Nam Theun National Protected Area, which borders
The natural flow of the water from the NT2 watershed is down the Nam Theun, into the Nam Kading, and from there into the
Most of the water release from the NT2 Reservoir happens at the other end of the reservoir and flows through an underground tunnel to the power station, and into a different river basin (hence NT2 often being called an “inter-river basin transfer project”).
If NT2 is operating at full power production, around 330m3 of water will be released from the power station (the natural flow ranges from around 10 to 2000m3 depending on the season) and into the regulating pond, from where it will flow through 27km of project built downstream infrastructure before being released into the Xe Bang Fai (point 3 on the map). As the name suggests, the regulating pond is designed to regulate how much of the power station’s release is allowed to flow on towards the Xe Bang Fai at any time. NT2’s downstream program is designed to mitigate and compensate for the impacts on communities caused by this change in flow.
So that’s ordinary operations. What happens during extreme weather?
Xe Bang Fai: There are around 150 villages along or close to the Xe Bang Fai that have been regularly impacted by the Xe Bang Fai flooding over the years. To avoid NT2 exacerbating the floods, the Nam Theun Power Company (NTPC) has a contractual obligation to cease power production when pre-defined flood risk levels are reached in the Xe Bang Fai.
The NT2 power purchase agreement with the Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT) recognizes this obligation, and there are no penalties for NTPC ceasing operation under these circumstances. During 2011, NTPC ceased generation in early July and again on August 2nd and didn’t restart for almost a month following particularly extreme weather in Khammouane, the province where NT2 is based. Water releases for the sake of NT2 reservoir dam safety are not made via the Xe Bang Fai, not only for the contractual reasons above, but also because the total amount of the water that can be released this way is around 330m3 – small compared to the volumes flowing into the NT2 Reservoir during extreme weather.
Nam Theun: If it becomes necessary to release water to avoid the dam overflowing, this is done via five gates at the dam wall, which release water into the Nam Theun. When required, releases are started in advance of extreme weather to ensure space in the reservoir, allowing the NT2 reservoir to reduce the impact of extreme weather on communities downstream of Nam Theun. It is important to remember that while NT2 may be releasing water into the Nam Theun during a flood, the same water would be flowing down the same river if the NT2 Reservoir wasn’t there. In fact, NT2 will reduce the impact of a flood by releasing water more slowly than it is flowing into the reservoir, thus helping to smooth the impact of natural events. This is what happened during a storm in early October. Prior to any significant releases of water, NTPC follows a pre-defined communications protocol that alerts government that water releases will be made.
The simple summary:
- Rain falls in the watershed (area 1) and flows into the NT2 reservoir where it is stored or released.
- A small environmental flow is released into the Nam Theun (area 2) all the time. If major water releases occur, they will be done via the dam wall’s gates (area 3), and will not be greater than the natural flow into the reservoir. In other words, they will not make floods from the Nam Theun worse compared to the way they would have been without the project.
- Water is released at up to 330m3 per second into the Xe Bang Fai during ordinary operations. Operations slow and then cease when pre-defined criteria are met to avoid exacerbating natural floods in Xe Bang Fai.
NT2 can assist in reducing impacts of flooding in local areas by slowing the flow of water released into the Nam Theun and helping interested communities around the Xe Bang Fai adopt submergent tolerant and late-season rice varieties that reduce the impact on food security of natural floods.