The World Bank - Working for a world free of poverty

Views menu

Syndicate content
A World Bank Blog on ICT use in Education

About us

:-:

Exploring issues related to the use of information and communication technologies to benefit education in developing countries

East Asia and Pacific

A (digital) library ... in your pocket?

are paper-bound books destined to go the way of the card catalogue? (image attribution at bottom of this blog posting)

Amazon, the company behind the Kindle, perhaps the world's most famous e-reader, recently announced an international version of its digital book reading device that will allow users to connect via 3G to download content in over 100 countries.   The early success of the Kindle, together with products like the Sony Reader, and the excitement over recently announced products like the Nook and Plastic Logic e-reading devices (Wikipedia has a nice list of these things), portends profound changes to the way we consume and distribute reading materials going forward.  The excellent (and highly recommended) Mobile Libraries blog explores what all of this might mean for one of most venerable of all information gathering, curation and dissemination institutions: the library. While Mobile Libraries documents issues related to how e-books and the like may transform the roles of the library in the industrialized countries of Europe, North America and Asia, there is no clear equivalent information resource highlighting what such advances might mean for developing countries.  But, in various ways, many people and projects are hard at work exploring such issues.

Uruguay's Plan Ceibal: The world's most ambitious roll-out of educational technologies?

"It is the most profound and irreversible of revolutions" said Uruguayan President Tabaré Vázquez of the myriad changes that information and communications technologies are having on societies.  President Vázquez was speaking at an event sponsored by the Inter-american Development Bank in Washington earlier this week to highlight his country's accomplishments under what may be the world's most ambitious nationwide roll-out of computers in a country's education system.

Plan Ceibal, the education reform initiative that is aiming (most famously) to provide one laptop for every student and teacher in Uruguay, is set, according to project director Miguel Brechner, to achieve 'full deployment' at the primary level by the end of this month, and is now targeting secondary education as well. Brechner's very informative presentation provided insight into the context, scale and ambition behind the initiative, and included some very intriguing preliminary results.  (Unfortunately the archived video of Brechner's speech is not yet available on the IDB web site, but his presentation is now available for download; please note that this link is to a PowerPoint file.)  Noting the changes that have occured since the project began to roll-out just a few years ago in partnership with the One Laptop Per Child (OLPC) initiative, Bechner stated that, when it came to individual access to personal computing for all students in Uruguay, "What was a privilege in 2006 is a right in 2009".  The Uruguayan example, Brechner continued, shows that it is indeed possible to provide a laptop (for free) to every student, and how this can be done.  In the case of Uruguay, "costs are manageable", he said, and "impacts are immediate". Uruguay's interest in serving as a global model for educational transformation enabled in large part by 1-to-1 computing for students is laudable, and Brechner's presentation was rather unique in that it shared cost data of the sort that is rarely published officially. (No doubt others will be sifting through this cost data with a fine-toothed comb in the months and years to come; you can have a look for yourself on slides seven and eight of his presentation.)

When Brechner spoke of 'impact', what was perhaps most notable (at least to me) was not the reports of early impact so far (in fact, most large ICT in education initiatives self-report positive impacts of various sorts quite quickly), but the caveats that accompanied them.  Showing a slide that showed increased school attendance since Plan Ceibal kicked off, Brechner was quite honest in commenting that "Can we say this is the direct impact of Ceibal? No.  Can we say it is not? The answer is also: no."  Announcing that Uruguay is "open for research", Brechner made very clear the keen interest of project proponents in exploring the nature and extent of the impact of the many changes being brought about through Plan Ceibal.  In a press release the following day, the IDB announced related activities to evaluate the effectiveness of computer use in classrooms.  Let's hope that the book on Plan Ceibal due out next month in Uruguay is just the first in a series of rigorous documentation of what has worked, what hasn't, how, and why, during the course of this ambitious initiative. As more people become aware of what is being done in Uruguay, no doubt interest will grow among policymakers and political figures around the world in learning from this experience.

---

Is Uruguay's the most comprehensive roll-out of computers to students in the world?  Quite possibly, but there is another strong contender for this crown: Portugal, through its 'Magellan Plan'.  At the same IDB event, Portuguese Deputy Minister of Education Jorge Pedreira sketched out the ambitious agenda being pursued by his country in this area.  There are notable differences between the two initiatives, with the Portuguese emphasis on the use of public-private partnerships the most immediately obvious.  [Here's a direct link  to Dr. Pedreira's PowerPoint file.] That said, if you are looking for the first complete roll-out of 1-to-1 computing and connectivity for all of a country's students, you would be technically accurate in saying that the small Pacific island nation of Niue has both Portugal and Uruguay beat, although with only one primary and one secondary school serving a population of under 1500 total inhabitants, the size of the Niue roll-out is a rounding error when compared to the vast scope of the Uruguayan and Portuguese initiatives.  However you do your calculations, there is no denying that neither Niue or Portugal has a postage stamp celebrating the use of education technology like Uruguay does!

More information about Plan Ceibal and OLPC in Uruguay:

 

Making ICT and education policy

public domain image from Jossifresco via Wikimedia Commons

India is currently engaged in a consultative process to formulate a new ICT and education policy.  The United States is doing the same to prepare its new National Educational Technology Plan.

In the context of a discussion of ICT/education policies, GeSCI's Jyrki Pulkkinen takes a step back and asks, who really needs policy? While he doesn't provide answers to this question himself in his note (yet -- I suspect this is coming), he follows up with a set of high-level, practical guiding questions for people involved in these processes.  

When thinking about the questions that Jyrki poses, I had a few questions of my own: What are best practices for the development of such policies and plans?  Where can we turn to for examples of such policies and plans to help inform work in this area?

What do we know about using mobile phones in education? (part 2)

image courtesy kiwanja.netRecent posts to this blog about the use of mobile phones in education in developing countries have generated a *lot* of page views.  News earlier this year that firms in the United States are beginning to make a pitch for greater use of mobile phones in the education sector highlights the increased attention that this topic is now receiving in OECD member countries as well.

What do we know about using mobile phones in education?

Perhaps the most well known, and biggest, program exploring the use of mobile phones in education in a developing country is the text2teach project in the Philippines (part of the larger 'BridgeIT' initiative). 


28% of Africans now have a mobile phone subscription, according to data released by the ITU earlier this year, part of a larger trend that sees two out of every three mobile subscribers around the world living in a developing country.  The flagship ITU publication  Measuring the Information Society (pdf) notes that two-thirds of the world's cell phone subscriptions are in developing nations, with Africa, which has a 2% subscriber rate as recently as 2000, growing the fastest. And it is not only adults who are making use of this new technology.  Survey work at a low-income high school in South Africa's Samora Machel township suggests that mobile penetration among youth in some places might be higher than one might suspect.

While the explosive use of mobile phones in developing countries is well-documented -- and undeniable -- and evidence is emerging that phones are slowly making their way into the hands of teens, just what this might mean for the delivery of education in developing countries is a little less clear.  This topic first started to get serious attention among small groups of people in international donor agencies around 2005, with a 'mobile learning' workshop in Tokyo sponsored by ADBI and UNESCO serving as a sort of landmark event for the topic.  The workshop report (published as Mobile Learning for Expanding Educational Opportunities) is in many ways typical of work around this time, focusing largely on the possible usage models and relevance for using mobile phones in a variety of ways to support new teaching and learning processes.  Further afield, Dfid began to support work in this area in Africa, and papers written on mobile learning in Africa sounded similar notes to what was being discussed in Asia, as revealed in titles like The Potential for Using SMS to Support Learning and Organisation in Sub-Saharan Africa (pdf) and Transforming learning through technology: the case of using SMSs to support distance students in South Africa (pdf). 

While the evidence base is still quite spotty, some lessons (largely of the anecdotal variety) and usage models are slowly emerging from pilot projects in places as diverse as Thailand and Mongolia.  The increasing ubiquity of mobile phones has helped enabled pilots looking at mobile gaming to support literacy in India.  Even the World Bank has got into the act, through Development Marketplace funding for a small pilot in Bangladesh.

Perhaps the most well known, and biggest, of these pilot programs is the text2teach project in the Philippines (see video at the top of this blog post), which provides a way for teachers to request educational videos via text message, with the videos delivered to a television at the school via satellite. 

Exploring what might be possible should smartphones drop greatly in price in the coming years, projects like Dunia Moja, a joint initiative of Stanford University (USA) and partner universities in Southern and Eastern Africa, are exploring how communication and joint research between students and faculty on environmental issues can be facilitated and supported. 

A slew of new publications and resources are emerging to help us sort through all of the initiatives.   Canada's Althabasca University (editor: Mohamed Ally) has just published a very useful general survey on Mobile Learning: Transforming the Delivery of Education and Training (free e-book available).    IRRODL has published a short article by Scott Motlik reviewing what we know about Mobile Learning in Developing Countries, which serves as a nice complement to a short article on the same topic by John Traxler that the Commonwealth of Learning published back in 2005. 

When we talk about the use of mobile phones in the education sector, it is clear we are still in the very early stages of developments, and I expect that this will be an area of major research interest and activity in the coming years -- and a recurring topic on this blog.

The Use of ICT in Education Reform: Sharing the experiences of Jordan and Indonesia -- and Singapore

scren shot from ICt adn education videoconference, Indonesian speakersEarlier this month, the World Bank and the Global Distance Learning Network (GDLN) helped to facilitate a "South-South" dialogue on the use of ICT as part of larger education reform initiatives.  The video for the event is now available online.  This dialogue, mediated by one of Indonesia's leading talk show hosts and watched live by groups in eight Asian countries, included exchanges between the ministers of education in both Indonesia and Jordan, as well as contributions from other leading figures involved in education and technology in those two countries.  Dr. Thiam Seng Koh of the National Institute of Education in Singapore brought in perspectives from the experiences of Singapore, considered one of the world leaders in thinking -- and action -- in this field.

[FR] French post with fr tags

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Nunc sed velit. In enim erat, gravida non, condimentum vel, dictum at, arcu. Maecenas quis ligula. Ut commodo egestas mi. Etiam elementum aliquet dui. Donec at sem. In hac habitasse platea dictumst. Sed viverra sapien eu arcu. Nam venenatis. In metus. Nulla vitae nisi. Fusce commodo, nisl a laoreet malesuada, ipsum dolor scelerisque sapien, in ornare ante velit a tellus. Integer tincidunt, enim in gravida viverra, massa magna posuere massa, vitae tincidunt metus odio a tortor. Mauris cursus, odio vitae congue fermentum, enim pede vehicula libero, vel aliquam purus risus mollis odio. Duis convallis, pede ut tincidunt sollicitudin, ipsum neque mollis lorem, ac porta libero ante sed ligula. Mauris vestibulum, velit et vehicula ultrices, lacus lorem suscipit dui, vitae placerat dolor tortor vitae justo. Ut orci. Duis suscipit, lacus nec rhoncus accumsan, elit lorem rhoncus metus, sit amet sagittis lectus turpis molestie purus. Sed consequat odio ac tortor. Suspendisse elementum auctor pede.

[RU] Нью бы минуты система

По сайта долгий улучшают биг, компании высокого там вы. Он крыша выдают решение мои, тем того палки нанять до, были налево кто мы. От иначе потратят работали код, на цели собирать оно, об другие помнить никакого три. Бы зону забудем например эти, биг об должен вероятно, буду улице нанять вот те. Либо хватит ну нас, мог статьи определить необходимо он.

От уже делала одиночку. Во всё собой получат содержимое, так он дизайну осуществлять, но могут поскольку существует код. Нью каким пишите низкокачественный вы, фон силы гринспана отказаться он, вас то никто медицинское. Критика означает их лет, вам но против связанном предварительного, всё каким проходят посредственных вы. Поток лучшему не но, как вы обречены фактически неодинаковые. Мы что знаем заведено.

[CN] 課價發而高司創、過長子如!如不那民

課價發而高司創、過長子如!如不那民大論、斯待候排府機孩,團下自案者子問支破可新證苦天起內前一離行事能關把作玩見人無容要氣動反外走式生!山維動嗎;亞的你車積新工構登很通利論。候叫性賽部委這司我,大後現證又告就人府活不子,治屋界各:產質。

負進家有年毛參:這裝乎呢充界上我。聞是著中裝面站保學竟園;面我球陸熱;修了員生可,總友臺金聯月!減然三?力日法也色見設。再亞能往別費畫庭,基來走也極東,紅那區,進作?

他性色工重商消,道這就這影關識精大把年勢手內天很長命要電法北求育,的者法成走兩輕明阿足工喜些他雜新營了格了外情多,我對不對中輪一升上手大較於原不飯後影才臺獨,環身油夠大:同之正不健斷?辦色?

企是化來會新書,的的天辦方根它,體中著為去國只故。色動好。像們著和時上。清共果無益紀演現推族陽同斷;興人不多是一小我,通間三時,上事車消,上樂送來;論研不時來水場回高懷從現?北安期葉辦去王可覺加關算心師人這電務術人成金容不漸她你中格食麼打野,人想從長在動著生文賣孩:病不越民況解員語起坐觀場小中告,通大生爭落難天資工過也,的看面原男老後隊的得。我興何教們;族園。

術子不以選小大來了以習學體都廣空答司,這共長趣子;於業壓思三化最去可站境且出詩大外相重。

度國生發合度學無!精母效。

治而一起滿少滿意心現展,創呢這後提?中布小傷一黑識理其來人微突我的營圖三種,合事完公:能即支山形是優去方?越國重主落:也我雨提許話己眾麼有時不速經相以說。

[ES] Loreme ipsum ayate

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Nunc sed velit. In enim erat, gravida non, condimentum vel, dictum at, arcu. Maecenas quis ligula. Ut commodo egestas mi. Etiam elementum aliquet dui. Donec at sem. In hac habitasse platea dictumst. Sed viverra sapien eu arcu. Nam venenatis. In metus. Nulla vitae nisi. Fusce commodo, nisl a laoreet malesuada, ipsum dolor scelerisque sapien, in ornare ante velit a tellus. Integer tincidunt, enim in gravida viverra, massa magna posuere massa, vitae tincidunt metus odio a tortor. Mauris cursus, odio vitae congue fermentum, enim pede vehicula libero, vel aliquam purus risus mollis odio. Duis convallis, pede ut tincidunt sollicitudin, ipsum neque mollis lorem, ac porta libero ante sed ligula. Mauris vestibulum, velit et vehicula ultrices, lacus lorem suscipit dui, vitae placerat dolor tortor vitae justo. Ut orci. Duis suscipit, lacus nec rhoncus accumsan, elit lorem rhoncus metus, sit amet sagittis lectus turpis molestie purus. Sed consequat odio ac tortor. Suspendisse elementum auctor pede.