The World Bank - Working for a world free of poverty

Views menu

A World Bank Blog on ICT use in Education

About us

:-:

Exploring issues related to the use of information and communication technologies to benefit education in developing countries

What do we know about using mobile phones in education?

See video

Perhaps the most well known, and biggest, program exploring the use of mobile phones in education in a developing country is the text2teach project in the Philippines (part of the larger 'BridgeIT' initiative). 


28% of Africans now have a mobile phone subscription, according to data released by the ITU earlier this year, part of a larger trend that sees two out of every three mobile subscribers around the world living in a developing country.  The flagship ITU publication  Measuring the Information Society (pdf) notes that two-thirds of the world's cell phone subscriptions are in developing nations, with Africa, which has a 2% subscriber rate as recently as 2000, growing the fastest. And it is not only adults who are making use of this new technology.  Survey work at a low-income high school in South Africa's Samora Machel township suggests that mobile penetration among youth in some places might be higher than one might suspect.

While the explosive use of mobile phones in developing countries is well-documented -- and undeniable -- and evidence is emerging that phones are slowly making their way into the hands of teens, just what this might mean for the delivery of education in developing countries is a little less clear.  This topic first started to get serious attention among small groups of people in international donor agencies around 2005, with a 'mobile learning' workshop in Tokyo sponsored by ADBI and UNESCO serving as a sort of landmark event for the topic.  The workshop report (published as Mobile Learning for Expanding Educational Opportunities) is in many ways typical of work around this time, focusing largely on the possible usage models and relevance for using mobile phones in a variety of ways to support new teaching and learning processes.  Further afield, Dfid began to support work in this area in Africa, and papers written on mobile learning in Africa sounded similar notes to what was being discussed in Asia, as revealed in titles like The Potential for Using SMS to Support Learning and Organisation in Sub-Saharan Africa (pdf) and Transforming learning through technology: the case of using SMSs to support distance students in South Africa (pdf). 

While the evidence base is still quite spotty, some lessons (largely of the anecdotal variety) and usage models are slowly emerging from pilot projects in places as diverse as Thailand and Mongolia.  The increasing ubiquity of mobile phones has helped enabled pilots looking at mobile gaming to support literacy in India.  Even the World Bank has got into the act, through Development Marketplace funding for a small pilot in Bangladesh.

Perhaps the most well known, and biggest, of these pilot programs is the text2teach project in the Philippines (see video at the top of this blog post), which provides a way for teachers to request educational videos via text message, with the videos delivered to a television at the school via satellite. 

Exploring what might be possible should smartphones drop greatly in price in the coming years, projects like Dunia Moja, a joint initiative of Stanford University (USA) and partner universities in Southern and Eastern Africa, are exploring how communication and joint research between students and faculty on environmental issues can be facilitated and supported. 

A slew of new publications and resources are emerging to help us sort through all of the initiatives.   Canada's Althabasca University (editor: Mohamed Ally) has just published a very useful general survey on Mobile Learning: Transforming the Delivery of Education and Training (free e-book available).    IRRODL has published a short article by Scott Motlik reviewing what we know about Mobile Learning in Developing Countries, which serves as a nice complement to a short article on the same topic by John Traxler that the Commonwealth of Learning published back in 2005. 

When we talk about the use of mobile phones in the education sector, it is clear we are still in the very early stages of developments, and I expect that this will be an area of major research interest and activity in the coming years -- and a recurring topic on this blog.

Comments

M-learning: next opportunity to learn and discuss face-to-face

Mike, you are right to say that we are at a very early stage. The WSIS Forum 09 (18-22 May 09) will, however, offer several opportunities to learn more about and discuss m-learning applications. One opportunity is the High-Level Panel hold on Wednesday 20 May, the other the e-learning Action Line meeting which will concentrate on m-learning (a few more lines on this below).

Mobile Learning : Effective Learning on Portable devices

While the mobile phone is the most widely distributed information device available to citizens around the world, challenges remain: technical (e.g screen and key size, multiple standards), socio-economic (e.g. privacy, cost barriers) and educational (e.g. m-learning theory, repurposing e-learning materials).
The e-learning Action Line meeting will build on the prior discussion of the High-Level Panel with a particular focus on mobile or m-learning. It will also be a continuation of the 2008 low-cost ICT devices session.
Many educational mobile learning uses have been explored: from low-cost mass learning opportunities through SMS, to edutainment, to data gathering (surveys, exams, questionnaires) to administrative and learning support, with very different mobile devices.
The session will combine a mix of presentation and discussion in the usual multistakeholder and open setting. UNESCO’s contact for this session is Cédric Wachholz (wsis@unesco.org).

re: M-learning: next opportunity to learn and discuss ...

Thanks for the comment and information, Cédric!
It is great that this topic is being included in the WSIS follow-up process. Unfortunately I will not be able to participate in next month's session in Geneva, but look forward to an update on what transpires there. Good luck with the event, which I imagine will be *at least* as thought-provoking as last year's session on low-cost ICT devices.

text2teach

I am not convinced that text2teach is a 'best' or 'good' practice in the use of mobile phones in learning. While text2teach is trying to solve the problem of lack of media rich content in the classroom, it is not the most cost effective way of solving said problem.

the text2teach solution is for teachers to request for media rich materials using text messaging (SMS), the material is then delivered via satellite, and downloaded to a Digital Video Recorder connected to a TV set in the classroom. to begin with why the need to send an SMS to order for the material? why not simply put all the media rich materials that will be used during the school year in a CD library or a server in the school? why pay for (expensive) satellite transmission when these multimedia materials can be saved in CDs and delivered via mail to the school at the start of every year? (this 'low tech' method of mailing CDs is being used by movie rental outfits in the US to deliver movies to customers and to get back movies from customers).

yes we can deliver media rich education materials to far flung schools the text2teach way, but why?

re: text2teach

Thanks for the comment, Boying. These are all very relevant questions that you pose.

The inclusion of text2teach here (and indeed, of any of the examples) was only meant to shine some light on some notable activities in this area, and not to imply that any of them represent good (let alone best) practice.

No matter the technology we are talking about, or its proponents, or the particular implementation, we always need to ask ourselves "why?". In the tech community, an acceptable answer is often 'because we can' (or perhaps more often, 'because it's cool!'). Novelty has its place in life, to be sure, and innovation often occurs in situations where one least expects it. When talking about the use of new technologies in resource-challenged educational environments, however, the bar for action should probably be higher than this. By saying this, I don't mean to argue against pilot projects, or even against experimentation, in such settings (far from it!). Rather, it is to sound a note of caution. One suspects that anything related to 'm-learning' is about to become the flavor-of-the-month in some educational technology circles.

Many people in the ICT4D community complain that we have 'too many pilots'. I actually feel the opposite way: We don't have enough of them. And by 'pilots', I mean 'well-documented projects designed to rigorously test a set of assumptions or hypotheses, especially where the lessons learned from such experiments might be scalable' -- and not just a 'small project', which is how many people seem to use the term.

I look forward to learning what we can from all of the pilots mentioned here (and others as well!). We hope to use this blog as one way to highlight emerging trends and issues in the ICT/education universe, provoking informed discussion and reflection along the way.

Text2teach is not good

I dont think its a good idea.Children learn more when they interact directly with the teacher.by introducing this technology of teaching it will make student dumb.

Text2teach uses educational

Text2teach uses educational videos (2-10 minutes), that help the teacher introduce the topic, not replace the teachers. After the video showing, there will be interactions of the class. This educational videos also have a corresponding lesson plan that guide the teacher on how it will be delivered. The teachers also underwent training to ensure their quality of teaching and how they will use the technology.

telephone engineers

Smart phones have hundreds of applications meant to educate kids — from graphic calculators to animation programs that teach spelling and phonics.

I too am skeptical if

I too am skeptical if text2teach is the best way to use cell phones in teaching students, but I do believe at this grade level any technology is good for them to be around. The other methods of e-learning with cell phones and internet are difficult because, as mentioned above, there are very high costs in developing countries' networking of such technologies, and there are many problems with the newer-tech items that are introduced in such countries at low-cost (look at beginning OLPC models).
Back on topic, I don't think it is a "dumb" idea at all to introduce these pilot programs into schools, especially at such a young age it is important to become familiarized with technology. Not only for later in life, but new/fun technology increases students' excitement to learn. One girl on the video even said that children come to school JUST for text2teach.

What is new since the last posting (2009)?

I am a belated reader of this blog. I am quite interested in the subject matter. I wonder what new developments have taken place since 2009. Can you point me to case studies, cases, and reports of projets and workshops. I apreciate those marked here (as links)- quite useful.

Hi Lewis, We'll have some new

Hi Lewis,

We'll have some new posts on this topic coming up shortly.

Thanks for the interest.

Cheers,
Mike

Text2Teach Project in the Philippines

Here are some links to recent news releases on Text2Teach Project implementation in the Philippines: http://rubycomm.wordpress.com/2010/08/26/187/ and http://technews.com.ph/?p=4691

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <br> <p>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.