Syndicate content

Computers in Secondary Schools: Whither India?

Michael Trucano's picture

The German scholar Max Müller famously remarked that "If I were asked under what sky the human mind has most fully developed some of its choicest gifts, has most deeply pondered on the greatest problems of life, and has found solutions, I should point to India."

No doubt there are many other countries also deserving of similar sorts of accolades, but the challenges that India currently faces related to providing universal access to a relevant and quality education for everyone -- and the solutions it deploys to meet such challenges -- are of increasing interest and relevance to people around the world. This is especially true as it relates to the use of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) to meet a variety of educational and developmental objectives.

All education systems are complex and varied, and India's is as complex and varied as any education system in the world. Only China rivals India in the vast scale of its education sector.While it is true that many schools in India are just now being introduced to computer use, India's first formal educational technology scheme started way back in 1972, during the government's fourth five-year plan.

Radio has been used effectively for many years to reach tens of millions of learners throughout India. The EduSat program to deliver educational television content by satellite officially launched in 2004, and, from its first use in schools in the south Indian state of Karnataka, EduSat now reaches over 100,000 secondary schools. In the state of Punjab alone, there are positions in schools for over 7100 dedicated ICT teachers!

Subhash Khuntia, the Joint Secretary for Secondary Education in the Ministry for Human Resource Development (MHRD), has outlined the potential relevance and use of ICTs within the government’s ambitious new scheme for universalization of access and improvement of secondary education, known as Rashtriya Madhyamik Shiksha Abhiyan (RMSA).

Depending on one's definition, the ICT component of RMSA may well become the world's largest ICT/education project (a title currently bestowed by many on the 'Distance Education to Eliminate Rural Povery' initiative in China). There are currently over 169,000 secondary schools in India, a number that will increase as the success of the government's push for universal primary education results in greater and greater demand for secondary school education.

One recurrent question centered on the relevance of the school computer lab model for ICT deployment to India. To a notable extent, some presenters and commenters called into question the appropriateness of creating special “computer labs”within schools. Better, these people felt, would be to have a smaller number of computers introduced directly into classrooms -- at least if the goal is, in the words of one participant, to 'transform teaching and learning through ICTs'. The fact that the impact of ICT use to date on learning outcomes is negligible in most places, at least partially attributable to the fact that, in most places, computers are only used to teach 'ICT literacy'. Putting computers into computer labs, overseen by computer teachers, pretty much ensures that they will *not* be integrated into normal teaching and learning processes. (A recent World Bank paper on school computerization in Colombia was cited in support of this argument.)

Notwithstanding some notable cases where computer labs are used regularly and creatively in direct support of a variety of subjects (like I have seen done well in schools in Thailand, to cite just one example), this argument has some very real merit. Indeed, one consistent message emerging from OECD countries is the importance of providing ICT access to learners within their learning environment, and not segregating computer access to special parts of the school building. (This sentiment is prominent in many educational initiatives promoting things like '1-to-1 computing' and 'ubiquitous learning', although these terms can mean different things to different people.)

That said, ambitious, complicated programs like RMSA typically have multiple goals. One counterargument to the 'no computer labs' sentiment goes something like this:

"Broadening access to ICTs, especially in rural areas, can be an important goal as well. In fact, this is not an either/or issue, and there is not one model of computer use in schools that will be relevant for all of India. ICT deployment into schools might be more usefully seen to happen in stages. In rural areas where there is currently little or no exposure to computers, and/or where there are not teachers competent in computer use, it would be inappropriate to simply put computers into classrooms immediately. Only once teachers and students (and school administrators) get more comfortable and adept at using computers does it make sense to begin to introduce them directly into classrooms. A very efficient way to achieve this sort of level of 'comfort' is through the delivery of ICT literacy courses. And it is important to note that putting computers directly into classrooms is an expensive deployment model!"

This discussion -- and many others -- will no doubt continue to pick up steam in the coming years as India makes increasingly large investments related to the use of ICTs in its education sector. If the high quality of discourse at this event is any evidence, there will be much from this experience from which all of us can learn.


For addition background information on the related consultation process that concluded last year in India, you may wish to visit the National Policy on ICT in School Education web site.

Check out the"Did You Know?" video on Youtube that presents a series of provocative statistics related to education, technology, economics and demographics.

A big hat tip to the Edutech Blog

Comments

Submitted by Christine Zarzicki on
I think India's approach to Information and Communication technologies is very appropriate and suitable for the current state of the country. Because exposure to computer systems and technology is sporadic and inconsistent throughout the nation, it seems very reasonable to establish protocol on a case-by-case basis. While computers in the classroom are essential for teaching students word processing, various programs and ultimately research, it is to be expected that this type of advanced instruction is only appropriate where computers have been used previously. Distinguishing between initial aptitude levels is crucial if learning efficiency is desired. That being said, the government’s impressive initiative for universalization of access and improvement of secondary education is one worth mentioning. In today's global economy it is necessary to keep current with technology in order to be competitive. In fact, it is virtually accepted that without computer literacy, modernization and "development" is almost impossible. It is unfortunate that humanity has become so dependent on technology, however it seems to be reality. In order for national economies to remain resilient and sustain their existence, ICTs have ostensibly become vital.

Add new comment