Syndicate content

Lost in a Foreign Land

John Stein's picture

Flamingos in an Indian wetlandHYDERABAD, India — It feels like a foreign land. Well, it is India, but that's not what I mean. Here I am, an infrastructure guy at the U.N. Convention on Biological Diversity's Conference of the Parties. What I am seeing in real time is global architecture at work on finding ways to protect the planet's natural resources in the face of manmade problems and changing climatic conditions. It is important work, and almost every country is laboring to find solutions that fit its unique needs. But you can imagine that common ground is not easily come by.

I find a session that piques my interest, with the bonus that the hall has a lightning-fast Internet connection and I can check my email while I wait for it to start. After the meeting comes to order, parliamentary procedure is under way, the minutiae of international negotiation begins, and delegations speak boldly of changing the word "identification" to "description." After a few minutes, I find even the fast Internet connection not enough to keep me there for the important but ponderous wordsmithing.

I have been asked to co-chair a World Bank side event on "Biodiversity as an Engine of Growth." It sounds great and I rely on my knowledgeable colleague, Anumpan Joshi, to brief me and give me the right messages to send. He does so brilliantly. My co-chair is to be a senior Indian professor, but he gets pulled at the last minute to something else and is replaced by the minister of environment from Bhutan. My first reaction is that this is an excellent coping action. His remarks later confirm that.

We hear a sharing of conservation and biodiversity cases that bring economics and benefit-sharing to the front of the debate, mainly the cases of India's tiger conservation program and its impact and potential for livelihood development for the poor. Next comes the Yosemite Park case in the United States, which argues so convincingly about how natural assets can be viewed as an economic engine for communities bordering the park. The numbers are enormous (around $800 million per year), combined with a jobs multiplier effect of over five for every federal job created. It goes over well with the crowd looking for evidence to sustain the theory of the importance of biodiversity and conservation for the region's poor. I certainly am convinced.

Next we hear about an initiative at Clemson University to create a network of global practitioners and a way to share best practices. It is getting ready to be rolled out and it generates excitement for its potential. We finally get to the Q and A (little time is left as always) and a speaker from Samoa expresses her concern that there is no female participant in the session and that these many poor people being discussed here have no one in the session to represent their views. We all agree that balance was lacking and we could have brought representatives to the session. I guess we are ingrained in some of our older patterns.  But as every cloud has a silver lining; it leads to an idea to use oral history to capture and put that information on Clemson's website, to allow poor people's views to be heard and disseminated.

The session is over. People express their thanks. And now it all seems to come together as we see the fit of the Bank's initiatives on Natural Capital Accounting, bringing in economics to the biodiversity debate along with building new partnerships, especially with the private sector.

What felt foreign now feels like home as we keep moving toward our mission — a world free of poverty.


Submitted by Kris Sid on
I found it interesting to see that even at a conference in India, where the marginalized are many times within arms reach (from those serving you tea to those laboring in struggling NGOs), the 'poor' was not adequately represented. I have found also in my studies of those working along the Ganga River that marginalized people not only require a platform to have their face shown but also the capacity to present their opinions clearly and confidently among those in power. I'm glad that this was brought up at the conference and an initial plan was laid out. I think the internet is a good platform which flattens communication putting people at more equal ground. I'm hoping to do the same to get their voices heard. I hope the World Bank continues to help secure the natural capital of the nation while keeping the poor in the conversation.

Submitted by Rajesh Rohatgi on
Enjoyed reading ....I particualrly found case studies interesting..perhaps need to showcase them more to our clients in region as well as within development community.

Add new comment