The World Bank - Working for a world free of poverty

Views menu

Syndicate content

blog.worldbank.org

How 'Civic Hacking' Answered Haiti Disaster

From the tragedy and wreckage of the Haitian earthquake come amazing lessons about how information technology and social media can bring help and hope to people trapped in catastrophic circumstances.

A good place to see how this is happening is the Social Entrepreneurship website.  Crisis camps of "civic hacking" throughout the U.S. and abroad are quickly producing base-layer maps that connect Haiti's thousands of orphans with potential adoption families, mobilizing speakers of Creole (photo), and delivering myriad other tech-driven emergency assistance with few layers of action-delaying bureaucracy.

The camps were set up by Crisis Commons, an international volunteer network of tech professionals.  The first CrisisCamp was actually held well before the Haiti earthquake -- in July 2009, at the World Bank.  Participants (scroll down to "Attendee List") included a rich cross section of representatives -- public, private, nonprofit -- from the sometimes rivalrous world of development aid.  "Us" and "them" suddenly became "we."

Civic hacking's Haiti successs stories are producing a flexible template for how emergency assistance can be delivered in other disasters, including those where climate change is at least a secondary cause, like storms and flooding.  Civic hacking's lessons will surely be extended to development aid in general, especially in countries with weak capacity.  Information technology can deepen and broaden capacity, and fast, as the proliferation of cellphones in Sub-Sahran Africa, South Asia, and other developing regions has been proving for years.

IBRD and IDA: Working for a World Free of Poverty.

Financial Reform and Fiscal Discipline

It was in 1714 that Bernard de Mandeville defended his view of the economic world in a long poem with pretensions to uncovering the moral basis of modern society – The Fable of the Bees: Private Vices, Public Benefits. According to him, industrialists, businessmen and politicians are like pimps, quacks, pickpockets and forgers: tireless professionals who, through their cunning, use the work of others for their own purposes. Mandeville claims that it matters little if every trade and place is tainted by trickery and every profession, by chicanery. What does matter is that everyone, whether saint or sinner, contributes to producing the comforts progress provides, by looking after their own interests.

But you and I believe that where people live off ill-gotten gains the community will suffer and, thus, we reject the poem’s cynical view of the world. Yet, the lesson of The Fable of the Bees (that civilization advances in the measure that individuals seek to satisfy their needs and desires) is still alive and kicking.

Conflict News Roundup

WORLD/ GENERAL

Quote of the Week

Requirements for a free and responsible press:

 

  • The media should provide a truthful, comprehensive and intelligent account of the day's events in a context which gives them meaning.
  • The media should serve as a forum for the exchange of comment and criticism.
  • The media should project a representative picture of the constituent groups in the society.
  • The media should present and clarify the goals and values of the society.
  • The media should provide full access to the day's intelligence.

 

Hutchins Commission on Freedom of the Press (1947)

Social Entrepreneur -- With an Emphasis on 'Entrepreneur'

We're hearing more and more about the "social entrepreneur" as the development community looks for new ways to achieve better results, especially with many developing countries struggling to meet their 2015 Millennium Development Goals and at the same time cope with destructive climate change.

Ashoka, itself a pioneer in social entrepreneurship, has a pretty good definition:

"Social entrepreneurs are individuals with innovative solutions to society’s most pressing social problems. They are ambitious and persistent, tackling major social issues and offering new ideas for wide-scale change."

But maybe the definition should also emphasize a special breed of social entrepreneurs -- those who tackle major social issues by launching projects that seek to be profitable.

When Fast Company magazine in 2008 honored 45 nonprofit social entrepreneurs "who are changing the world," it also tipped its hat to 10 for-profit companies with social missions.

Trying to change the world with a project funded by development donors can be maddeningly frustrating.  Even with a successful pilot, a nonprofit company is likely to encounter repeated funding snags and gaps in its quest for sustainability and replication.

Joel Selanikio was a Marketplace 2003 winner with the innovative idea to collect health-care data with hand-held computers.   DataDyne, the company that pediatrician Selanakio and his partner, technologist Rose Donna, co-founded, is a not-for-profit limited liability corporation (LLC).  Its personal digital assistant -- EpiSurveyor -- was an immediate success in health care in Sub-Saharan Africa and other developing countries.  But Selanikio had to keep making the rounds of donors for each step of his growth.  He was the model of the "ambitious and persistent" social entrepreneur -- but: "I got tired wearing out the knees of my trousers" making successive proposals to development donors, he said in an interview.

Knowledge leaves the universities... fast.

Big changes happening in education:  Great article on Innovating the 21st century University by Don Tapscott and Anthony D. Williams.  And take a close look at the New York Times Knowledge Network, a brand- new approach that combines a global brand, knowledge, university partnerships, on-line learning, and vast marketing expertise. Think what this could look like in five years, and what is now possible to deliver to the developing world.

Maybe this explains why last week Alex Herder, a 25-year old friend and entrepreneur in animation about difficult topics like HIV prevention, told me, "You know in ten years, no one is going to be paying tens of thousands of dollars for four years at a university." I am beginning to believe him.  Think how that would level the playing field between rich and poor -- and it's already well underway.

Here's how it all connects to the Development Marketplace mission.  Innovation depends on knowledge.  Lack of access to knowledge has always been a severe constraint for developing countries.  But the signs are clear -- university-level education is becoming much more available to a global audience.  Aleem's post two days ago about the decentralization of knowledge frames the changing situation nicely. 

The opportunities and challenges for those of us based in organizations such as the World Bank Institute engaged in capacity development and training delivery to developing nations are enormous.  Can we keep up?  Even more importantly, will we lead?

 

Do Cities Matter?

It is a paradox that India which is among the most densely populated countries in the world, is also among the least urbanized. The figure below compares urbanization rates with income for more than 100 countries. It shows that an increase in urbanization rate is positively associated with real per capita income. This is the iron law of development—i.e., growth is associated with the reallocation of labor and capital away from traditional (rural) sectors to modern (urban) sectors. Spatial transformations that give rise to urbanization accelerate growth because households and firms benefit from scale economies, mobility, and specialization. Increased urbanization contributes to growth, job creation and poverty reduction. This can indeed become a virtuous circle.

South Korea's Experience with the Financial Crisis of 07/09

The Republic of Korea’s economic history---insofar as financial crises are concerned---has been a mixed bag. It successfully navigated the emerging market debt crises of the early 1980s, but the Asian crisis of 1997/98 hit the economy especially hard. Korea’s experience with the current global crisis has been somewhat less painful than the severe shock the economy went through in 1998, but it has nonetheless experienced significant spillover effects as a consequence of the crisis. Between August 2007 and November 2008, the won lost almost 50 percent of its value, before recovering a good share of its value with a 20 percent appreciation (see figure).

Equity markets have followed a similar pattern, with the benchmark KOSPI 200 index falling to a low of 948 points in November 2008 (from 2,054 points a year before) before regaining to current levels at 1,684 points. Other financial sector indicators, such as interest rates and capital flows, have demonstrated signs of stress. Capital inflows, for example, fell sharply during the crisis, with portfolio and FDI contracting by 47 and 31 percent, respectively (see figure).

Korea’s real economy, however, has fared relatively better through this current episode, especially compared to the Asian crisis. To be certain, as an export-oriented open economy, it has experienced slowdowns along with the rest of the world. However, net exports remained remarkably robust through the crisis, and GDP has fallen markedly less than in 1997/98 (see figure). Likewise, investment has remained strong throughout most the period---it dipped slightly below 2 percent on a year-on-year basis for two quarters, and has since returned to positive territory---in contrast to the large declines in 1998. Importantly, Korea has also not faced balance of payments difficulties this time round that would necessitate IMF assistance.

What is most remarkable is that the strong (relative) economic performance of Korea this time round has occurred in an environment of very weak global demand. Although the region underwent a severe recession during the Asian crisis, it was able to muster a V-shaped recovery, largely on the back of export recovery fueled by healthy demand in the developed world (mainly the United States). This time, with the epicenter of the crisis in the developed world, the ability of Korea to weather the storm has been admirable. Indeed, the Development Prospects Group's forecast for 2010 and 2011 has the East Asia and Pacific region leading global recovery with 8.1 and 8.2 percent growth rates, respectively, and Korea is expected to follow the region in exiting the global recession.

Another thing that makes Korea's sidestepping of a crisis more amazing is the debt context in which all this has occurred. Corporate debt is at an elevated level (113 percent of GDP in 2008), which is comparable to levels prior to the Asian crisis. Bank lending to households reached about 40 percent of GDP. Together, these account for about 150 percent of GDP. The government fiscal balance, at KRW 33.0 trillion, is 3.2 percent of GDP for 2009, and expected to grow to KRW 49.8 trillion (4.7 percent of GDP). While the future is never certain, the significant compression on credit default swap spreads for major Korean financials and corporates (see figure) suggest that the storm has passed, at least for now.

What enabled the Korea to weather the current crisis? Some would argue that Korea's reserve war chest has something to do with it. Indeed, recent research has shown that countries with larger reserve holdings have managed to maintain the strength of their currencies through the crisis, regardless of their current account balances or short-term debt levels. While the jury is still out on the specifics of the Korean case, a better understanding of the role of reserves in crisis mitigation will certainly be illuminative.

Prospects Daily: U.S. factory orders increase, while those in Germany decline in December

Important developments today:

Global markets: Stocks and oil down; U.S. treasuries up.

U.S. factory orders increase

German factory orders disappoint

On the Move podcast looks at the Haiti earthquake

On the Move with Georges Collinet

Georges Collinet, host of the popular On the Move with Georges Collinet podcast, recently recorded a new podcast episode about the Haiti earthquake and its aftermath, taking a look at the situation room at the World Bank and featuring an interview with World Bank Task Team Leader Nicolas Peltier Thiberge who has just recently returned from Haiti.

The podcast is currently only available in French, but we're working on getting the English version up soon. You can listen to the French podcast using the embedded player below:
 

Download MP3
 

 

Puppet Masters in the Newsroom

There are places in the world that appear to be democratizing.  Their governments claim to be working toward institutionalizing a free press.  But authoritarian control can still be imposed behind the curtain of make-believe.  Let me share a real-world example from a country that shall remain unnamed.

A colleague in international development, let’s call him Abdul Kanak, is originally from a self-professed newly-democratizing Asian country.  We met up for coffee recently, and he told me about how things really work in his country’s media sector.  Having worked as a journalist before moving to the United States, Abdul experienced firsthand how the government effectively controlled the mainstream news media and its coverage of political issues.  Two forces worked in tandem to create the conditions for control.  First, concentration of ownership among privately-owned news organizations.  Second, the placement of cronies in positions of influence within the newsroom. 

Media Effects III: Framing - "Melting Ice Caps or No More Ice Age?"

After introducing agenda setting and priming, I want to complete the "holy trinity of media effects" with a short introduction of framing, which I consider to be the most important effect of this threesome. Whereas agenda setting tells us what to think about (by putting issues on the public agenda), framing tells us how and why to think about an issue. To frame means to communicate in a way that leads audiences to see something in a certain light or from a particular perspective. Aspects that are not included in the frame do not come to the audience's attention. Framing determines where the audience puts its attention. Effective framing taps into preexisting beliefs, attitudes, and opinions; it highlights certain aspects of an issue over other aspects.

Prospects Daily: U.S. non-manufacturing sector activity expands after three months

Important developments today:

Corporate bond risks in Europe to fall.

U.S. services sector expands after 3 months.

Poland's budget deficit to reach 7.5 percent of GDP in 2010.

Knowledge in the era of decentralization

Working in the innovation space actually means thinking a lot about how we source and organize knowledge. That's definitely an area that is changing fast. Here's how I am thinking about what this means for the World Bank.

We're moving away from a world in which knowledge is centralized and resides primarily in any one organization, even an organization as complex as the World Bank or even a university. Web 2.0, particularly interactive platforms such as blogs and other social media tools, now makes it possible for a wide range of actors to co-create, critique, and share knowledge in a variety of ways. What that means for institutions that aim to be knowledge centers is that they will have to source knowledge from wherever it lies (infrequently in one place), interact with it (critique it, interpret it, build upon it), and connect increasing numbers of people to it.

Evaluating the One Laptop Per Child Initiative in Sri Lanka

how do we know she's learning? | image attribution at bottomThe Sri Lanka Ministry of Education (MOE) recently decided to pilot the One Laptop Per Child (OLPC) program by purchasing laptops from the OLPC Foundation, with funding from the World Bank, and distributing them to 1,300 students in selected primary schools throughout the country. The scheme may eventually be scaled up, depending upon the educational benefits of the pilot stage.

China grew faster than its target and most projections in 2009 – what are the key takeaways?

Click image to enlarge.

China’s economy grew 8.7 percent in 2009. This was more than the 8 percent target, despite the global recession that caused global output excluding China to fall about 3 percent. China’s growth outcome is substantially higher than projections made in early 2009. For instance, in our  World Bank quarterly economic update (of which I am the lead author) we projected 6.5 percent GDP growth and some other forecasts were even lower (see Figure 1).

How did these forecasts come about, and what lessons we can draw from the experience of China’s growth in 2009? I cannot speak for my colleagues at the World Bank, let alone for other economists. But, all in all, while I have learned important lessons, I am not sure how differently I would see and do things if again presented with a situation like we were in a year ago.

Global Imbalances: Can Hegelian Philosophy Help?

A mini-civil war has been going among macroeconomists in recent years over the issue of global imbalances (the existence of large, sustained current account deficits in some countries that are compensated by equally large and sustained external surplus in others). On one side, a prudent, if not pessimistic view considers large imbalances as evidence of problems with the international monetary and financial system, and symptoms of domestic distortions (mainly in the United States and China). On the other side, a relaxed, if not optimistic view suggests that global imbalances are not anomalies but simply the predictable outcome of a world with increasingly globalized financial flows in search of the right mix of risks and returns. The former view prescribes that the two largest countries in the world rebalance their economies to avoid the potentially painful cost of disruption and adjustment. The latter contends that global imbalances will be corrected through time by the normal functioning of market forces.

While these two opposing views often rely on some well-constructed theoretical and empirical underpinnings, they suggest a dichotomy that may not allow grasping fully the issues at hand. The main issue with large current account deficits (see figure) is obviously their sustainability, that is, whether they will be met by sufficient, timely and affordable inflows of foreign capital. In the case of the US for instance, it bears on the questions of (i) the size of the financial obligations that the deficit reflects, (ii) the availability of income payments and receipts that will eventually be paid out of the economy’s production—with the risk of reducing current consumption and investment, and (iii) the confidence in creditor nations or in the low probability of sudden swings in the mood of foreign investors.

Source: World Bank

The truth is that despite their rivalry, the US and China have become economically and financially so interdependent that one needs to go beyond the traditional narratives of external imbalances, which have focused on the analysis of national accounts, trade flows, and financial flows. Hegel’s dialectics of lordship and bondage (also known as master and slave), may be quite helpful in explaining the persistence of external imbalances in the US and China. A joke by comedian Jon Stewart on the TV program The Daily Show can help make the point. Poking fun at President Barack Obama for his decision to delay a meeting with the Tibetan leader Dalai Lama in favor of strengthening relations with China, Stewart said sarcastically: “We don’t want to upset China! Gosh!... Imagine what they would put in our toys and toothpaste if we upset them!...” Like most TV jokes on international economics, this one was quite tasteless. Still, it made a couple of interesting points: it highlighted the reliance by US on China as the source for a large fraction of consumer goods for its large domestic market. Perhaps more important, it conveyed the implicit acceptance (which almost rises to the level of addiction) by American households and firms of these cheap imports from a country often viewed with suspicion by politicians and located thousands miles away.

My new paper on Hegelian Macroeconomics offers a more nuanced view and argues that a more complete understanding of global imbalances requires a multidimensional perspective that more fully takes into account events beyond traditional macroeconomic variables. Global imbalances are neither just a temporary aberration that can be addressed through economic policy actions in the U.S. and China as suggested by proponents of the first view, nor are they only the result of globalization as implied by proponents of the second view. While agreeing with the need for the U.S. and China to take corrective action, it also suggests that eliminating global imbalances will require structural changes—some of them well beyond the realm of economics—that may take a long time to materialize.

Зуд: Байгалийн энэхүү гамшиг нь Монголын мал аж ахуйд болон малчдын амьжиргаанд хүндрэл учруулж байна

Get the flash player here: http://www.adobe.com/flashplayer
Hover over "Notes" for photo information. View photos large.

(Originally published in English.)

Өнөөдрийн байдлаар Монгол Улс ихээхэн хэмжээний цас, хүйтэн хавсарсан цагаан “зуд” хэмээх байгалийн гамшигт нэрвэгдээд байна. Энэ нь зундаа ган гачигтай байснаас бэлчээрийн хомсдолд орж, өвс тэжээл хангалттай базаах боломж олгоогүй улмаар өвөлдөө цас их орж, салхилан цаг агаар хэвийн хэмжээнээс доогуур болж хүйтний эрч эрс чангарсантай холбоотой.  Бэлчээрийг үлэмж их цас дарж, мал сүрэг бэлчих аргагүй болж, өвс тэжээлээр гачигдан зутрах зэрэг өвлийн улирлын нөхцөл байдалд зуд болдог.

Why Climate Adaptation Has to Begin at Home

DM2009 finalists focused on community-based adaptation (CBA) to climate change because the struggle against intensifying drought, storms, flooding, and rising sea levels in developing countries often must begin not in national ministries but at home.  Why that's so is summed up cogently in this slide show from CARE, the global  organization that focuses on helping the poorest individuals and households  The slide show was presented at the pre-Copenhagen U.N. climate meeting in Poznan, Poland, in December 2008, but it's as relevant today as it was then.  Maybe more so.

Prospects Daily: Global equities bounce back from 3-month lows

Important developments today:

Global equities bounce back from 3-month lows

German retail sales increased in December

Brazil’s industrial production posts record year-over-year growth in December

A conversation on migration and development

I was recently interviewed by Kanchan Banerjee, the editor of New Global Indian. The interview touched on many aspects of migration and development that may interest you. Thanks to Kanchan for giving us permission to reproduce the interview below.

KB- About half a decade ago, you were among the first in the world to figure out the first global tally of remittances, what was the result?

DR-The money that migrants send home turned out to be way larger than I expected, the finding actually stunned experts in the field. Gathered from a trickle of hard-earned cash, believe it or not, remittances are larger than $300 billion a year. Compare that with official aid flows which are just about $100 billion a year.

KB-Today you are a leading figure in the area of Migration and Development. What are the factors that attracted you to work on the two related areas of development in today's inter-connected world?

DR- As a migrant myself, I am deeply interested in the phenomenon of migration and remittances. Before Y2K, I was actually talking with friends about starting a money transfer service to India from the US! The main reason for my interest in migration is that it produces instant poverty corrupt practices. This enables a poor person to hold his/her head high in the society. When migrants send money, it helps not only the immediate family members and friends, but also indirectly the local community. I call remittances 'value-added money' because it is not only the dollar that comes in, each dollar also comes with advice on what to do with it. Also remittances are friends in foul weather they increase when the recipient is facing difficult times. There are about 200 million migrants worldwide, supporting as many if not more people at home. That suggests that remittances may reach almost a tenth of the world's population.