Rethinking India’s public transport after the COVID-19 lockdown is over


This page in:

Enhancing the safety of bus transport will be the biggest challenge to redefining urban mobility in the aftermath of the pandemic. Photo: Shutterstock
Enhancing the safety of bus transport will be the biggest challenge to redefining urban mobility in the aftermath of the pandemic. Photo: Shutterstock

In India, like in so many other parts of the world, the coronavirus (COVID-19) has struck a massive blow to public transport.  

Last week, to better understand the impact of the pandemic, we surveyed both public and private bus operators, in partnership with the International Association of Public Transport, UITP. 

The survey showed that bus services have almost ground to a halt, down by 98-99 percent from before the pandemic.   Operators are losing huge revenues but still have to pay staff salaries and repay loan installments. In a sector with razor-thin margins, this double whammy has proved to be devastating. All told, the city, intercity, and rural bus industry is losing about $7 billion for every month of inactivity.

Meeting staff expenses has emerged as the biggest financial challenge. Typically, salaries account for almost half the expenses of public bus operators. Servicing debt repayments came up as the second most important issue.

Keeping cities moving after the lockdown

Even when the lockdown is over, challenges will persist to contain COVID-19, keep cities moving, and ensure the financial survival of the industry. 

Enhancing the safety of bus transport will be the most pressing issue. Across the world, operators have begun readying for this time by developing protocols and procuring protective equipment to maintain higher hygiene standards and protect staff and passengers. India can help restore users’ trust in public transport by creating a COVID-19 Green Label , which shows that operators have met standards and are ready to restart operations.

Dramatic and dynamic changes in demand and supply will require great agility to keep cities moving.

While demand is uncertain, planning services is another challenge. In the first month after the lockdown, transport activity is expected to be at 25 to 50 percent of its pre-coronavirus levels. In Beijing, for comparison, the Beijing Transport Institute estimated that, on March 29, 2020, about one month after the end of lockdown, private cars on road were at 71% of normal value, shared bicycle at 62%, and bus, subway, and taxi at 30%. To ensure their safety, many people may temporarily shift to less public modes of transport. At the same time, the carrying capacity of buses will drop due to social distancing requirements.   

Such dramatic and dynamic changes in demand and supply will require great agility to keep cities moving. Digital platforms will need to be leveraged to adjust and communicate bus schedules. Social distancing will require working hours to be proactively staggered to reduce peak demand.  And the lower carrying capacity of buses will mean that underutilized private buses will need to be mobilized to keep cities moving.

What’s more, after the deep losses incurred during the lockdown, social distancing will cut revenues by half, leading to losses for each trip. Meanwhile, sanitizing buses and providing protective equipment to drivers will increase costs. Buses will not be able to operate for very long without support, funding, and access to liquidity. To help tide them over this critical period, survey respondents indicated a need for support to meet salaries for up to three months, reschedule debt – both principal and interest – and waive taxes for up to three months to reduce costs. 

Alternative to cash payments during COVID-19 (Coronavirus)
Moving from cash to digital payments

To help their bus operators survive financially, India’s states could start thinking about a combination of interventions.  These could include introducing temporary tax waivers, extending the validity of various documents – fitness certificates, permits, insurance – improving the efficiency of services with dedicated bus lanes, developing card and digital payments, relaxing some permit restrictions to mobilize private buses, and allocating a larger share of urban mobility resources for bus transport. One solution could include providing access to a stabilization fund, backed by future revenues from the sector, through a coordinated approach between the central government and the states.  

Countries are taking different measures to ensure the survival of their public transport. For example, Hong Kong (SAR), China, introduced direct support to taxi and minibus drivers and owners and reimbursed 100 percent of regular repair and maintenance costs and insurance premiums for six months for its franchised bus and ferry operators. In the United States, $25 billion of Federal Transit Administration emergency transit funding have been allocated to support transit systems in preventing, preparing for, and responding to COVID-19.

An opportunity to promote sustainable mobility

The recovery period will also be an opportunity to shape new forms of mobility that provide good access for all, clean air, reduced congestion, and reduced crash fatalities. Mexico City, Bogota, Oakland, Lima, Berlin, London, Wuhan, Milan, Paris and New Zealand offer many examples of how urban mobility is being rethought with the rapid rollout of walking and cycling infrastructure at low costs while creating space for other sustainable options over a longer time horizon.

bogota transport
Bogota, Colombia; Photo Credit: World Bank Photo Collection

And as in the rest of the world, the post-recovery period in India too is likely to see a rise in home-based work and schooling, walking, cycling and the use of public transport. More so because of India’s high-density urban agglomerations and its vast numbers of low- and middle-income urban families for whom public transport often provides a lifeline. This is a good time to build upon the lessons of this crisis and rethink the new normal. 

With contributions from Ravi Gadepalli and Tatiana Peralta Quiros
Kulwant Singh
August 19, 2020

We need to ensure collective mobility in the Indian Cities by using more technology making paperless systems.

Rashmi Fauzdar
August 19, 2020

A good analysis of scenario in India and elsewhere. The situation looks alarming and given India may not support it's private players to the extent done by China and Hongkong or USA.

Alok Badkul
August 19, 2020

The public transport in India , is already overloaded . Even the private operators which operate low cost local transportation , connecting villages to cities and vice versa , thrive on taking more than seated capacities. It’s only economic way for them to survive. If social distancing norms are to be implemented in them ( though it may be impossible) , the number of vehicles plying have to increase by at least three folds and this kind of investment with negative returns won’t be done by any private operator . Needless to say this has to be carefully drafted PPP arrangement, where the loss during COVID lockdown and social distancing is borne by government and later adjusted against the revenues accruals. Entire cycle may take about 7-10 years. The over seating may return back soon as soon as the economics will force people to move out of their homes for maintaining their lifelines .

August 19, 2020

It’s indeed necessary to rethink the new normal

Kulwant Singh
August 19, 2020

Excellent and timely

Virendra Tiwari
August 19, 2020

The tax exemption and relaxation in transpot formalities along with subsidy for an year can kick start transport sector in India after unlock period in this era of pandomic # Covid19.

Parimal Godse
August 19, 2020

Love to hear innovations and policy framing in sustainable transport