Really investing in poor people

This page in:

No, I don't mean investing in health systems, education, sanitation, etc. I'm talking about taking an equity stake in the future earnings of poor people. This is an idea mooted in a science fiction novel called The Unincorporated Man and subsequently discussed on Overcoming Bias and Marginal Revolution (hat tip to both). This is the first I've heard of the novel, so I'm relying on Marginal Revolution for a synopsis:

The Unincorporated Man is a science fiction novel in which shares of each person's income stream can be bought and sold.  (Initial ownership rights are person 75%, parents 20%, government 5%--there are no other taxes--and people typically sell shares to finance education and other training.)

The hero, Justin Cord a recently unfrozen business person from our time, opposes incorporation but has no good arguments against the system; instead he rants on about "liberty" and how bad the idea of owning and being owned makes him feel.  The villain, in contrast, offers reasoned arguments in favor of the system.

Both blogs discuss this as a theoretical, in-the-distant-future possibility. But there is already a company doing exactly this in the education sector. It's called Lumni, and it is the brainchild of Miguel Palacios, a professor at Vanderbilt University. Students at Lumni don't get loans - they get financing, and in return they subsequently pay back a percentage of their income over some agreed number of months. The amount they pay back may end up being more or less than the amount they originally received.

Unfortunately, many who first encounter this idea find it morally repugnant. Isn't this akin to indentured servitude? I actually think there is a lot to be said for this model. A student who is investing in his or her education faces a very risky proposition - while the returns to investment in education are high on average, there tends to be a pretty high degree of variation. This model helps share the risk between the financier and financee, one of the principle goals of a well-functioning financial system. The crux is making sure that a company like Lumni doesn't have a say in the student's choices once the deal has been made (in contrast to the dystopic world of The Unincorporated Man.) 

What say readers of the PSD blog? Should IFC start promoting equity markets in human capital in developing countries?

For more background on the concept, start with Palacios's Cato paper on human capital contracts


Ryan Hahn

Operations Officer

Join the Conversation

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly
Remaining characters: 1000