The last coal mine in Wałbrzych, Poland closed in the 1990s, leaving a region that had long relied on mining facing severe economic disruption. Unemployment soared, local businesses suffered, and an entire way of life built around the coal industry seemed to disappear overnight. By 2000, only one-tenth of the jobs lost in the mining sector had been replaced, leaving thousands without livelihoods.
This scenario is playing out in coal regions worldwide as the global economy transitions to lower-carbon growth. Yet Wałbrzych's subsequent journey offers valuable insights into how employment challenges can be addressed during climate transitions.
A Tale of Two Transitions
The initial years after Wałbrzych's mine closures were devastating for workers and the local economy. But the establishment of the Wałbrzych Special Economic Zone in 1997 marked a turning point. The zone offered tax allowances and specialized information services to attract new businesses and investment to the region.
Over time, the strategy began to bear fruit. Multinational companies including Toyota, Electrolux, and Cadbury invested in the region, creating more than 50,000 jobs by 2020. The transition wasn't perfect—early support for coal workers was inadequate, and some investments weren't in low-carbon sectors. However,it demonstrated how deliberate economic diversification strategies can generate substantial employment after coal.
Similar transformation occurred in Germany's Ruhr region, once dominated by coal mining and steel production. By capitalizing on existing regional strengths, the Ruhr developed new economic sectors including modern logistics, environmental services, renewable energy manufacturing, and cultural tourism. Two of the world's leading producers of wind turbine parts began as manufacturers of coal-mining machinery in the Ruhr.
Jobs at the Center of Climate Action
The shift to a low-carbon economy is essential for mitigating climate change, but it represents one of our era's greatest employment challenges. With millions of workers employed in fossil fuel and carbon-intensive sectors, the transition risks significant job displacement if not properly managed.
This is particularly true in regions dependent on coal mining, oil and gas extraction, or carbon-intensive manufacturing. These communities often face limited economic diversification after decades of specialization in single industries, making them especially vulnerable to transition shocks.
The Private Sector's Critical Role in Job Creation
With the private sector accounting for approximately 90% of employment in many developing countries, businesses are essential partners in creating and maintaining jobs during the transition. The newly released World Bank's Just Transition Tool for Private Sector Activities provides actionable guidance for governments to develop economic strategies that leverage private investment for employment creation.
The private sector's role centers on five employment-focused areas:
- Productive Investment for Job Creation: Directing investments into sustainable sectors that maximize employment creation.
- Innovation for New Employment Fields: Developing new products and business models that create diverse job opportunities.
- Workforce Development: Implementing reskilling initiatives that prepare workers for new employment.
- Local Economic Development: Investing in community infrastructure that sustains local employment.
- Employment-Focused Policy Engagement: Communicating with policymakers about barriers to job creation.
Real-world examples demonstrate this approach in action. In Penang, Malaysia, the government partnered with industry to resolve skills mismatches through the Penang Skills Development Center. Government support included providing land and buildings for skills centers, grants for operational costs, and tax incentives for companies that invested in training. The focus on vendor development programs helped upgrade capabilities of local suppliers through training and linkages with multinational firms.
Building an Ecosystem for Employment Growth
Creating employment-rich transitions requires coordination across multiple stakeholders and a comprehensive approach. South Africa's Presidential Climate Commission has established a framework for its just transition that emphasizes creating decentralized economic opportunities, especially for women and youth.
Successful strategies typically include:
- Regional economic strategies prioritizing job creation in sustainable sectors
- Green industrial ecosystems supporting employment concentration
- Dedicated support for SMEs and entrepreneurs as key job creators
- Workforce development programs aligned with industry needs
- Effective governance mechanisms to coordinate employment-focused strategies
In Australia's Latrobe Valley, following a coal plant closure in 2016, authorities established a Supply Chain Transition Program providing tailored support to affected businesses. Companies received up to AUD71,000 (about USD45,000) along with specialist assistance to develop Business Transition Plans identifying new market opportunities.
From Employment Challenge to Opportunity
The evidence from successful transitions shows that deliberate employment-focused strategies can generate more jobs in emerging green sectors than are lost in declining carbon-intensive industries. Pakistan's tree-planting initiatives and Ethiopia's National Green Development program have created hundreds of thousands of jobs while contributing to environmental restoration.
In the Philippines, the Green Jobs Act established a legal framework requiring various government agencies to develop skills requirements for green jobs, maintain a database of green careers, and implement skills training programs. The Act introduced financial incentives including tax deductions of up to 50 percent for firms investing in training activities.
The global shift to a low-carbon economy presents both employment challenges and opportunities. By focusing on practical policies that promote economic diversification with job creation at their core, regions can navigate the complex challenge of maintaining and creating employment throughout the climate transition.
Communities like Wałbrzych, the Ruhr region, and others demonstrate that with strategic planning, targeted investments, and commitment to employment outcomes, the necessary shift to a low-carbon economy can become an opportunity for economic renewal rather than decline.
Join the Conversation