AI in Education: A Privilege for the Few or an Opportunity for All?

To integrate AI or not to integrate AI in education systems, that seems to be the question. However, posing it may remain a privilege for the few rather than a possibility for the many. In Lima's gleaming bilingual private schools, students engage in lively debates with AI-powered chatbots about Shakespeare's emblematic characters such as Hamlet himself. Meanwhile, in the rural highlands of Cajamarca, many classrooms still lack electricity, let alone connectivity. This stark contrast isn't just a tale of two Perus but of the global education landscape as artificial intelligence ushers in a new era of learning.

There is much talk about the potential of AI in education but less about how the rapid rise of generative AI is dramatically widening the digital divide. This widening gap is manifesting in three distinct groups of students:

1. The AI-Empowered: In well-resourced, tech-savvy urban centers, some students are guided by trained educators to harness cutting-edge AI tools. They use AI to enhance critical thinking, engage in deeper learning, and develop socio-emotional and technical skills.
2. The AI-Dependent: Some students in areas with good connectivity are using AI to "delegate" their homework and academic tasks. While they have access to technology, they miss essential learning experiences and skill development.
3. The AI-Excluded: In many parts of the world, students struggle with access to even the most fundamental resources. For them, AI-enhanced learning remains a distant concept. Their teachers see AI instruction only in news and social media, lacking minimum skills or grappling with basic connectivity issues.

In low and middle-income countries, the third group is still the largest. This three-tiered reality raises urgent questions: As AI reshapes education at breakneck speed, how can we ensure it becomes a bridge rather than a barrier? How do we address the gap in access and the divide in effective, teacher-guided use of these powerful tools?  The challenge ahead is to ensure the effective and ethical use of AI across all student groups. It's about transforming the AI-Dependent into the AI-Empowered and speeding the inclusion of the AI-Excluded in this educational revolution. The focus must be on leveraging AI to create more equitable, effective, and engaging learning experiences for all students.

Opportunities Amidst Challenges

When properly integrated, AI can be a powerful educational tool. It can customize learning to individual student needs, encourage critical thinking, and prepare students for better opportunities in an AI world. For teachers, AI can act as a co-intelligence, boosting their productivity and effectiveness.

The key lies in how we approach AI integration. We need affordable connectivity and devices, adequate school infrastructure, and – most importantly – capable and digitally literate teachers. This last point cannot be overstated. In many middle-income countries, the share of teachers with sufficient AI and digital literacy to effectively use AI in their practices is still low. Without addressing this, we risk a scenario where students adopt AI faster than their teachers, potentially leading to unsupervised and unproductive use of these powerful tools. Or any unpredictable scenario.

 A Proactive Approach: The World Bank's Perspective

At the World Bank, we're advocating for a proactive approach, focusing on human capabilities while responsibly integrating AI. Three key actions are crucial:

1. Ensure a highly skilled and digitally literate teaching workforce. The teaching career must be recognized as both demanding and challenging, and therefore highly valued and rewarded. There is a growing gap between the increasingly challenging characteristics of the career and the social and economic recognition of the career, particularly in low- and middle-income countries.  Teacher selection, initial training, and continuous professional development should address the profession's increasingly complex demands, including AI and digital literacy. Education systems like those in Japan and Luxemburg are adopting teacher training that combines theory and practical instruction on ethically integrating AI tools. Pioneers in the global south, such as Nigeria (Edo), South Africa, Rwanda, Brazil (Matto Grosso), and Chile, are designing holistic training incorporating AI.
2. Invest in an enabling digital ecosystem for effective technology use in education. An enabling ecosystem includes affordable  high-speed internet access, appropriate devices, adequate school infrastructure and robust digital platforms. However, in most cases, this ecosystem to support the adoption of digital learning and AI tools does not exist, particularly in low and middle-income countries. The World Bank and the IDB have launched a shared agenda to improve access to connectivity, devices, educational platforms, and digital skills in Latin America.
3. Develop AI-ready curricula and foster research in AI for education. Curricula should provide students with skills needed in the AI world, aligned with national goals and international standards. Countries like China, Korea, India, United Arab Emirates have incorporated AI into their curricula, some since primary level. In Uruguay, Ceibal has developed a framework to teach AI in schools. Simultaneously, investing in AI research in education at the national level is crucial. Supporting AI R&D in collaboration with higher education institutions and the private sector can foster innovation and expand AI expertise. Finland and Singapore are leaders in this field, while in Latin America, new research centers are emerging in Brazil and Chile.

The Path Forward

The path forward is about finding a balance between traditional education and AI-supported learning that leverages the strengths of both. It's the balancing act of using technology to amplify teachers' strengths.

As we stand at a pivotal moment in education, the choices we make today will shape the learning experiences of millions of students worldwide. By addressing the digital divide, ensuring equitable and responsible access to AI tools and knowledge, and investing in the teaching career, we can empower learners and teachers. The AI revolution can support a transformation of education ecosystems, making them more inclusive, effective, and innovative – an opportunity for all, not just for the privileged few. But there is urgent homework for that to happen. 

Subscribe and receive a weekly article